When I was a young nun, I had a few doubts about Benedict’s eighth degree or step of humility; I still have doubts now I’m older, but the basis has changed. Benedict says
The eighth step of humility is for a monk to do only what is recommended by the common rule of the monastery and the example of his superiors [alternatively, ‘seniors’]. RB 7. 55
My younger self noted the use of the word ‘monk’, which for Benedict is never neutral but implies someone doing his best to live up to the monastic ideal, and heartily concurred with the wisdom of following the Rule as master, but I sometimes wondered about following the example of my monastic seniors. When one lives cheek by jowl with others, every little flaw becomes visible and it is only in the novitiate that one ever meets the perfect monk. A few years on and the imperfect monk shows his true colours. The only way I could make sense of what St Benedict asked was to see it as an exercise in trust; and of course, it does take great humility to trust weak and fallible beings and submit to them, laying aside one’s own ideas.
My older self sees things slightly differently. I have come to realise that the eighth degree lays on the seniors the obligation of being trustworthy, of setting a good example to others. It requires something of the same humility in laying aside one’s own ideas about what is best, accepting that one is oneself weak and fallible and that one’s imperfect best is, in fact, the best one can offer.
For both young and old the repository of wisdom we call the Rule is our guide, but it is a guide that must be constantly interpreted afresh in the concrete situations of our daily life. My younger self and my older self may practise this step of humility in slightly different ways, but it is the same kind of humility that is striven for. To trust another is an act of faith. It involves a surrender into the hands of God, but not God clearly seen but rather the God we perceive dimly and sometimes uncertainly in the face of those we live with in community. It is ultimately another preparation for the surrender we will all one day make in death.