The Problem with Indignation

We all know what makes us indignant. Sometimes our outrage is accompanied by a nice warm glow of self-approval as we condemn what everyone else seems to accept uncomplainingly: war, poverty, disease, that sort of thing. I exaggerate, but for a reason.

There is a lot of indignation circulating online at the moment, but I’m not sure it is achieving anything very much or that it is always genuine, in the sense that it represents a truly compassionate response to a grave situation. The problem with indignation is that it often generates more heat than light. Our emotions are worked up, but our brain cells barely function. We seethe at the Save the Children report that over 1,700,000 children in Yemen (yes, you read that right, one point seven million) are severely undernourished and in need of ‘protective assistance’ because of war, but we do not know what to do about it. We may sign a petition; we may give money to aid agencies; but beyond that, we are at a loss. It is at that point that something sinister often seems to happen. We begin to feel guilty, as though we were responsible for what has happened, or, worse, we try to pin the guiilt on another. It helps if the other is an institution of some sort — a government, a church, an -ism of some kind. Either way, our indignation is in danger of feeding on itself because, of course, neither we nor the institution that becomes the focus of our rage is necessarily capable of changing things. That is particularly true, I think, when we are talking about the situation in non-Western countries. Our indignation gets us nowhere; it clouds what little vision we have and may even work against what we hope to achieve because anger feeds anger.

To return to that terible statistic about Yemen. We must translate that statistic into nearly two million children’s faces — children who, if they grow up at all, will always bear in their bodies and minds the dreadful consequences of these years of malnourishment and conflict. This morning the media are awash with reports of the terrible bombings in Jakarta and Diyarbakir, and rightly so; but those children, who will plead for them? More to the point, who will be prepared to give up an entrenched position so that they may live? We in the West earnestly desire peace for the people of Yemen, Syria and wherever there is conflict. We know perfectly well that the reasons for the present conflicts are many and various, but ultimately all our efforts, all our indignation, will avail nothing unless the people fighting one another want to change. Our prayer today must surely be for a change of heart, for an overcoming of every obstacle — in ourselves, as in others.


7 thoughts on “The Problem with Indignation”

  1. Is having empathy with or concern for all those people round the world suffering from the effects of conflict and neglect the same as indignation? What I or any other individual thinks counts for very little in isolation. But unless we are free, able and willing as individuals to concern ourselves with the causes of and possible solutions to these problems, how are these problems to be resolved?
    The Pope, the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Dalai Lama command sufficient esteem and respect throughout the corridors of world power that should they so choose to comment upon any given situation, world leaders and organisations may be persuaded to react or intervene to remedy a situation.
    Ignorance of a problem is the greatest obstacle to identifying and implementing viable solutions for tackling the problem. Our prayers, concern and actions as individuals are hopefully and collectively recognised as being helpful for those in need.

  2. Thank you for this. I thought you were going to discuss institutions, churches taking on board guilt from the past and feeling compelled to apologise for wrongs over which they had no control and that in turn leading to indignation. At least he moment I,as a member of a church (I,m thinking here of the Anglican Church)I am being urged to apologise for discrimination which I abhor.
    Surely we have to return to the fact that “love is all”. Mutual tolerance and understanding, as far as possible, automatically follows, doesn’t,t it? Sometime we can,t understand everything, but we agree to liv with a certain level of uncertainty for the sake of peace.

  3. Please note I have corrected the figures in this blog post after further checking — I made the mistake of following an erroneous source. There are, apparently, over 7 million children in Yemen, which has a current total population of 26+ million. Save the Children has identified 1.7 million children as at major risk. The figures change daily, but there is clearly a major crisis in the country.

Comments are closed.